Contact Us

For Marketing, Sales and Subscriptions Inquiries
Rockefeller Center, 45 Rockefeller Plaza
20th Flr Unit #5, New York, NY 10111
United States

Conference List

Quarterly Journal of Econometrics Research

June 2020, Volume 6, 1, pp 1-11

Panel Data Estimators in the Presence of Serial and Spatial Correlation with Panel Heteroscedasticity: A Simulation Study

Nwakuya Maureen Tobechukwu


Ijomah Maxwell Azubuike

Nwakuya Maureen Tobechukwu 1 ,

Ijomah Maxwell Azubuike 1 
  1. Department of Mathematics/Statistics University of Port Harcourt, Choba, Rivers State, Nigeria. 1

Pages: 1-11

DOI: 10.18488/journal.88.2020.61.1.11

Share :

Article History:

Received: 03 August, 2020
Revised: 07 September, 2020
Accepted: 21 September, 2020
Published: 05 October, 2020


Panel data analysis is often faced with the issue of errors having arbitrary correlation across time for a particular individual “I” (serial correlation) and/or errors having arbitrary correlation across individuals at a moment in time (spatial correlation) with error disturbances having non constant variance. This study examined some panel data estimators in the presence of serial and spatial autocorrelation with panel heteroscedasticity. The study was done using two different sets of data simulated separately with ?=0.95 & 0.50. For each set of simulations short and long panels were considered for different sample sizes. The analysis considered two settings were rho is considered to be panel-specific (?i) and where rho is considered to be common for all panels (?). The estimators were examined based on bias, overconfidence and relative efficiency. The results produced evidence that the size of the autocorrelation coefficient ? affects the general performance of an estimator. Comparison of the estimators showed that Panel Corrected Standard Error Estimator (PCSE) produced better results than the other estimators considered in this work. But it was seen not to do very well in small samples and short panels. In terms of relative efficiency Park-Kmenta estimator was found to be more efficient that PCSE and PWLS (Panel Weighted Least Square Estimator). This paper has been able to show that the size of rho at the long run has an impact on the performance of the estimators, it showed that a small size of rho tends to increase overconfidence. The paper also revealed that Park-Kmenta estimator even with its flaws is still the most efficient estimator compared to the PCSE and PWLS. and it also substantiated the fact that PCSE performs badly in samples especially when N>T.
Contribution/ Originality
This study is one of the few studies which have investigated the effect of the size of autocorrelation coefficient on the estimators based on the flaws of Parks-Kmenta estimator, which has mislead most researchers into becoming more inclined to use PCSE without considering others credits of Parks-kmenta estimator.


Panel heteroscedasticity, Panel corrected standard errors, Park-Kmenta estimator, Autocorrelation coefficient, Overconfidence.


Baltagi, B. H., & Griffin, J. M. (1988). A generalized error component model with heteroscedastic disturbances. International Economic Review, 29(4), 745-753. Available at:

Baltagi., B. H. (2005). Econometrics analysis of panel data. Chichester: Wiley.

Baltagi.., B. H., Bresson, G., & Pirotte, A. (2006). Joint LM test for homoskedasticity in a one-way error component model. Journal of Econometrics, 134(2), 401-417. Available at:

Beck, & Katz. (1995). What to do (and not to do) with Time-Series Cross-Section Data. American Political Science Review, 89(3), 1-14.

Bera, A. K., Sosa-Escudero, W., & Yoon, M. (2001). Tests for the error component model in the presence of local misspecification. Journal of Econometrics, 101(1), 1-23. Available at:

Cameron, A. C., & Trivedi, P. K. (2005). Microeconometrics: Methods and applications. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building.

Galbraith, J. W., & Zinde-Walsh, V. (1995). Transforming the error-components model for estimation with general ARMA disturbances. Journal of Econometrics, 66(1-2), 349-355. Available at:

Holly, A., & Gardiol, L. (2000). A score test for individual heteroscedasticity in a one-way error components model, Chapter 10 in J. Krishnakumar and E. Ronchetti, eds., Panel Data Econometrics: Future Directions (pp. 199–211). North-Holland, Amsterdam.

Holton, G. A. (2014). Value-at-risk theory and practice (2nd ed.). New York: San Diego, Chapman & Hall/CRC.

Hong, Y., & Kao, C. (2004). Wavelet-based testing for serial correlation of unknown form in panel models. Econometrica, 72(5), 1519-1563. Available at:

Kmenta. (1986). Elements of econometrics (2nd ed.). new York: Macmillian.

Lejeune, B. (2006). A full heteroscedastic one-way error components model for incomplete panel: maximum likelihood estimation and Lagrange multiplier testing (pp. 1–28). CORE Discussion Paper 9606, Catholic University of Louvain

Miller, S., & Startz, R. (2018). Feasible generalized least squares using machine learning. Available at SSRN 2966194.

Moundigbaye, M., Rea, W. S., & Reed, W. R. (2018). Which panel data estimator should I use? A corrigendum and extension. Economics: The Open-Access, Open-Assessment E-Journal, 12(2018-4), 1-31.

Nwakuya, M., & Nwabueze, J. (2016). Relative efficiency of estimates based on percentages of missingness using three imputation numbers in multiple imputation analysis. European Journal of Physical and Agricultural Sciences Vol, 4(1), 63-69.

Parks, R. W. (1967). Efficient estimation of a system of regression equations when disturbances are both serially and contemporaneously correlated. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 62(318), 500-509. Available at:

Romano, J. P., & Wolf, M. (2017). Resurrecting weighted least squares. Journal of Econometrics, 197(1), 1–19. Available at:

Roy, N. (2002). Is adaptive estimation useful for panel models with heteroscedasticity in the individual specific error component? Some Monte Carlo evidence. Econometric Reviews, 21, 189-203.


Google Scholor ideas Microsoft Academic Search bing Google Scholor


This study received no specific financial support.

Competing Interests:

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.


All authors contributed equally to the conception and design of the study.

Related Article

( 1 ) Study of the Relationship between Economic Growth and Inflation: Application to the Countries of the South Side of the Mediterranean: A Panel Data Approach
( 2 ) Panel Data Analysis of the Impact of Economic Freedom as Well as Economic Conditions, The Quality of Life, and Public Education Spending on U.S. Undocumented Immigrant Settlement Patterns
( 3 ) Purchasing Power Parity Hold in Major SAARC Countries? Panel Cointegration Analysis
( 4 ) Effect of Budget Defict on Private Investment in East African Community for the Period 1981-2015: A Panel Data Analysis
( 5 ) Public Sector Size and GDP Growth Nexus: Panel Data Estimation
( 6 ) An Empirical Investigation into the Key Drivers of Economic Performance in the CEMAC Zone: A Panel Corrected Standard Errors Approach
( 7 ) Panel Data Estimators in the Presence of Serial and Spatial Correlation with Panel Heteroscedasticity: A Simulation Study
( 8 ) Financial Risks in Turkish Banking Industry: A Panel Data Analaysis on Istanbul Stock Exchange
( 9 ) Economic and Noneconomic Forces on Remittance Receiving: A Panel Analysis of Top Remittance Sending Countries towards Bangladesh
( 11 ) Measuring Efficiency in Banks: A Brief Survey on Non – Parametric Technique (Data Envelopment Analysis)
( 12 ) The Lead-Lag Relationships between Construction Investment and GDP: Granger Causality Tests and Impulse Responses Using Japanese Data
( 16 ) An Investigation of the Relationship between Manufacturing Output and Economic Growth : Evidence from Nigerias Data Set
( 17 ) Financial Market Predictions with Factorization Machines: Trading the Opening Hour Based on Overnight Social Media Data
( 18 ) Forecasting Equity Index Volatility: Empirical Evidence from Japan, UK and USA Data
( 20 ) The Impact of Data Frequency on the Level of Exchange Rate Pass-through to Consumer Prices in Nigeria
( 26 ) The Correlation Between the Palestinian Civil Society Institutions and the Universities (Status: The Palestine Technical University Kadourie with Tulkarm Institutions)
( 27 ) Correlation between Financial Difficulties and Financing Strategies among Market Stallholders in Batangas City
( 29 ) Can the Interdependence Effect and the Contagion Phenomena be Related with One Another?
( 30 ) An Inventory Model with Lost Sale is Time Dependent
( 31 ) Ensuring Quality Provision of Education for All: Discovering Challenges Faced by Teachers of Students with Learning Disabilities in Regular Primary Schools in Masvingo District
( 32 ) Stock Market Index Prediction with Neural Network during Financial Crises: A Review on Bist-100
( 33 ) A Review upon the Changes Which Come With the Model upon Turkish Metropolitan Municipality within the Provincial Administrative Boundaries
( 34 ) Milk or Wine: Are Critical Infrastructure Protection Architectures Improving with Age?
( 36 ) Rural - Urban Balance as a Measure of Socio-Economic Development with Special Reference to Iran
( 37 ) A Review on EU Transportation Projects within the Case of Turkey for European Union Regional Development Policy
( 38 ) Studying the Integration of Damascus Securities Exchange with Selected Stock Markets
( 39 ) Testing the PPP Using Unit Root Tests with Structural Breaks: Evidence from Politically Unstable Arab Countries
( 40 ) Specifying Quality of Governance in Transition Economies with Cluster Analysis
( 42 ) Triple Hurdle Model with Zero Expenditures
( 43 ) Satisfaction with Applications Fuels the Growth of Mobile Wallet Use in Thailand
( 44 ) Analysis of Effect of Profitability, Capital, Risk Financing, the Sharia Supervisory Board and Capabilities Zakat in Islamic Perspective with Circular Approach Causastion on Islamic Banks in Indonesia
( 45 ) The Effectiveness of the Production of Healthy Rice in Comparison with other Rice Varieties in the Upper Northern Region of Thailand
( 47 ) Assessing Access to Comprehensive HIV Treatment Services for Men Who Have Sex with Men and Female Sex Workers in the Bamenda Health District
( 58 ) Agent-Based Simulation of Contribution Games
( 60 ) Study on Environment and Energy Using Belonging Materials
( 61 ) Kashmir Peasant Economy under Dogra’s: A Case Study of Agrarian Produce and Livestock 1885-1925 A.D
( 62 ) Driving Role of Institutional Investors in the Indian Stock Market in Short and Long-Run – An Empirical Study
( 63 ) Promoting Entrepreneurship through Open and Distance Education in Zimbabwe. A Case Study of the Zimbabwe Open University Students at Masvingo Regional Campus
( 64 ) Geographical Starting Points the Analysis of Current Rural Problems in Montenegro: Case Study of Rural Local Community Kralje
( 66 ) A Study of Transnational and Transformation Leadership Styles and Factors Affect The Leadership Style
( 67 ) Impact of Microfinance Lending On Economic Growth of Third world Nations: Study of Nigeria
( 68 ) The Recruitment of Migrant Workers in the Food Service Industry in Malaysia. A Study of Old Town White Coffee and Pappa Rich Kopitiam
( 69 ) Challenges and Survival Strategies for Women in Small Scale Catering Business: A Case Study of Siyaso Magaba, Mbare
( 70 ) A Mixed-Methods Study to Explore Stage of Readiness and Intention of Micro and Small Enterprises to Adopt Mobile Money in Indonesia
( 71 ) Attributes Influencing Strategic Alignment in the Service Sector: An Indonesian Banking Sector Case Study
( 72 ) Micro-Credits and Poverty Reduction in Dar-Es-Salaam, Tanzania: A Case Study of Dar-Es-Salaam Commercial Bank
( 73 ) An Assessment of the Impact of Information Communication Technology (ICT) On the Administration of Public Records: A Case Study of the Bolgatanga Municipal Assembly in the Upper East Region of Ghana-West Africa
( 74 ) The Mediating Effect of Market Orientation on the Relationship between Entrepreneurial Orientation Dimensions and Organizational Performance: A Study on Banks in Libya
( 75 ) Opinion of Parents about Child Labour and Their Education – A Study
( 76 ) Measuring the Quality of Islamic Banks Services and Its Impact on Customers Satisfaction A Survey Study on the Islamic Banks Customers in Lattakia-Syria
( 77 ) The Internal Branding Process: Customer Reprofiling and Brand Positioning (Empirical Study on Traditional Snack Food in Bandung-Indonesia)
( 78 ) Managerial Judgement Versus Financial Techniques in Strategic Investment Decisions: An Empirical Study on the Syrian Coastal Region Firms
( 79 ) Confirming the Mediation Effect of A Structural Model By Using Bootstrap Approach: A Case Study of Malaysian 8th Grade Students’ Mathematics Achievement
( 81 ) Market Share and Profitability Relationship: A Study of the Banking Sector in Nigeria
( 82 ) The Effect of Public Debt on Domestic Product and Unemployment (An Empirical Study on the Palestinian Economy)
( 83 ) A Theoretical Analysis Upon the Environmental Health and Justice Issue: A Case Study for a Comparison Between G20s Unitary and Federal Members
( 84 ) A Factor Analysis Approach Towards a Study of the Factors Affecting Students’ Choice of Higher Education Institution: A Case Study of a Private Institution (Twintech International University College of Technology)
( 85 ) Effects of Environmental Satisfaction on Family Displacement Case Study: Gohar Dasht Region, Karaj City
( 86 ) Measuring the Quality of Health Services in Lattakia Province Patients' Perspective (Field Study of Health Centers in Jableh City)
( 87 ) Rice Farmer and Capital Formation: A Case Study of Rice Farmer's Credit Cooperative in Itoikin, Ikosi-Ejirin LCDA, Lagos State