Contact Us

For Marketing, Sales and Subscriptions Inquiries
Rockefeller Center, 45 Rockefeller Plaza
20th Flr Unit #5, New York, NY 10111
United States

Conference List

Journal of Forests

June 2021, Volume 8, 1, pp 13-22

Selection of Superior Clones by the Multi-Dimensional Decision-Making Techniques in Scots Pine Seed Orchard

Erol Imren


Rifat Kurt


Cengiz Yucedag


Nebi Bilir


Halil Baris Ozel


Mehmet Cetin


Hakan Sevik

Erol Imren 1 Rifat Kurt 1 Cengiz Yucedag 3

Nebi Bilir 4
Halil Baris Ozel 5
Mehmet Cetin 6
Hakan Sevik 7

  1. Department of Forestry Industry Engineering, Faculty of Forestry, Bartin University, Bartin, Turkey. 1

  2. Department of Landscape Architecture, Faculty of Engineering & Architecture, Burdur Mehmet Akif Ersoy University, Burdur, Turkey. 3

  3. Department of Forest Engineering, Faculty of Forestry, Isparta University of Applied Sciences, Isparta, Turkey. 4

  4. Department of Forest Engineering, Faculty of Forestry, Bartin University, Bartin, Turkey. 5

  5. Department of Landscape Architecture, Faculty of Engineering and Architecture, Kastamonu University, Kastamonu, Turkey. 6

  6. Department of Environmental Engineering, Faculty of Engineering and Architecture, Kastamonu University, Kastamonu, Turkey. 7

Pages: 13-22

DOI: 10.18488/journal.101.2021.81.13.22

Share :

Article History:

Received: 09 April, 2020
Revised: 11 January, 2021
Accepted: 22 January, 2021
Published: 04 February, 2021


The living conditions of living beings are becoming ever more difficult due to the climate change caused by industrialization. Forests, which have a great importance in terms of natural resources, are one of the main elements which prevent this situation. Therefore, it is important to ensure the sustainability of forests and to increase their genetic and structural quality. Appropriate farms and clonal seed orchards should be established with the purpose of achieving this genetic diversity. This way, quantitative traits of clones, which are located in these seed orchards, depending on their growth performance, the cone yield can be determined. In this study, the best clones in terms of cone yield were determined through MAUT and WASPAS methods, which are some of the multiple criteria decision-making techniques. This was done by using the height and diameter measurements of 30 Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) clones selected according to random sampling method in 3 different blocks in Erzurum region. Based on the sum product assessment and multi-attribute utility theory model results, clones 22 and 29 were determined as superior and prospective for further breeding procedures in terms of seedling height and root collar diameter. According to the entropy method, the maximum weights for seedling height and root collar diameter were obtained in Block-3 with 0.580175 and in Block-1 with 0.590017, respectively.
Contribution/ Originality
This study plays important role in selecting the best clones in terms of cone yield through MAUT and WASPAS methods, which are some of the multiple criteria decision-making techniques.


Clone, Multi-dimensional decision-making technique, Pinus sylvestris, Root collar diameter, Seedling height.


[1]          M. Cetin, F. Adiguzel, S. Gungor, E. Kaya, and M. C. Sancar, "Evaluation of thermal climatic region areas in terms of building density in urban management and planning for Burdur, Turkey," Air Quality, Atmosphere & Health, vol. 12, pp. 1103-1112, 2019. Available at:

[2]          M. Cetin, "The effect of urban planning on urban formations determining bioclimatic comfort area’s effect using satellitia imagines on air quality: A case study of Bursa city," Air Quality, Atmosphere & Health, vol. 12, pp. 1237-1249, 2019. Available at:

[3]          FAO, "The state of the world’s forests 2018 - Forest pathways to sustainable development," Rome. Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO, 2018. Retrieved from:

[4]          H. B. Ozel and N. Bilir, "Fertility variation and status number in a clonal seed orchard of Scots Pine (Pinus sylvestris L.)," Fresenius Environmental Bulletin, vol. 24, pp. 2035-2038, 2015.

[5]          T. Yangin and N. Bilir, "Interaction of cone production and growth characters in Brutian pine (Pinus brutia Ten.) populations," Research and Reviews in Biotechnology and Science, vol. 9, pp. 6-10, 2014.

[6]          M. Gunes and N. Umurusman, "A decision support tool fuzzy target programming tax optimization applications in local governments," Review of Social Economic & Business Studies, vol. 2, pp. 242- 255, 2003.

[7]          A. Ishizaka and P. Nemery, Multi-criteria decision analysis, methods and software. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, 2013.

[8]          B. H. Massam, "Multi-criteria decision-making techniques in planning," Progress in Planning, vol. 30, pp. 1-84, 1988. Available at:

[9]          A. F. Howard, "A critical look at multiple criteria decision making techniques with reference to forestry applications," Canadian Journal of Forest Research, vol. 21, pp. 1649-1659, 1991. Available at:

[10]        R. L. Keeney, Value-focused thinking: A path to creative decision analysis. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1992.

[11]        S. A. Hajkowicz and T. Prato, "Multiple objective decision analysis of farming systems in goodwater Creek Watershed, Missouri," Research Report No. 24, Centre for Agriculture, Resources and Environmental Systems, Columbia, Missouri1998.

[12]        J. Ananda and G. Herath, "A critical review of multi-criteria decision making methods with special reference to forest management and planning," Ecological Economics, vol. 68, pp. 2535-2548, 2009. Available at:

[13]        P. Chatterjee and S. Chakraborty, "Material selection using preferential ranking methods," Materials & Design, vol. 35, pp. 384-393, 2012. Available at:

[14]        M. Karaatli, N. Omurbek, I. Budak, and O. Dag, "Ranking of liveable cities with multi criteria decision making methods," Selçuk University Journal of Institute of Social Sciences, vol. 33, pp. 215-228, 2015.

[15]        FGD, "The State of seed orchard in Turkey," Annual Report, Forest General Directorate, Ankara2001.

[16]        H. Zhang, C.-l. Gu, L.-w. Gu, and Y. Zhang, "The evaluation of tourism destination competitiveness by TOPSIS & information entropy–a case in the Yangtze River Delta of China," Tourism Management, vol. 32, pp. 443-451, 2011. Available at:

[17]        A. Shemshadi, H. Shirazi, M. Toreihi, and M. J. Tarokh, "A fuzzy VIKOR method for supplier selection based on entropy measure for objective weighting," Expert Systems with Applications, vol. 38, pp. 12160-12167, 2011. Available at:

[18]        S. Cakir and S. Percin, "Measurement of R&D performance by integrated entropy weight-TOPSIS method in EU countries," Uludağ University, Journal of Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, vol. 32, pp. 77-95, 2013.

[19]        T. C. Wang and J. C. Hsu, "Evaluation of the business operation performance of the listing companies by applying TOPSIS method," 2004 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics, vol. 2, pp. 1286-1291, 2004.

[20]        J. Wu, J. Sun, L. Liang, and Y. Zha, "Determination of weights for ultimate cross efficiency using Shannon entropy," Expert Systems with Applications, vol. 38, pp. 5162-5165, 2011. Available at:

[21]        X. Li, K. Wang, L. Liu, J. Xin, H. Yang, and C. Gao, "Application of the entropy weight and TOPSIS method in safety evaluation of coal mines," Procedia Engineering, vol. 26, pp. 2085-2091, 2011. Available at:

[22]        M. Islamoglu, M. Apan, and A. Oztel, "An evaluation of the financial performance of REITs in Borsa Istanbul: A case study using the entropy-based TOPSIS method," International Journal of Financial Research, vol. 6, pp. 124-138, 2015. Available at:

[23]        K. Karakuş, D. Aydemir, A. Öztel, G. Gunduz, and F. Mengeloglu, "Nanoboron nitride-filled heat-treated wood polymer nanocomposites: Comparison of different multicriteria decision-making models to predict optimum properties of the nanocomposites," Journal of Composite Materials, vol. 51, pp. 4205-4218, 2017. Available at:

[24]        H. Gumus, D. Aydemir, E. Altuntas, R. Kurt, and E. Imren, "Cellulose nanofibrils and nano-scaled titanium dioxide-reinforced biopolymer nanocomposites: Selecting the best nanocomposites with multicriteria decision-making methods," Journal of Composite Materials, vol. 54, pp. 923-935, 2020. Available at:

[25]        P. C. Fishburn, "Methods of estimating additive utilities," Management Science, vol. 13, pp. 435-453, 1967. Available at:

[26]        R. Keeney and H. Raiffa, Decisions with multiple objectives: Preferences and value trade-offs. New York: Wiley, 1976.

[27]        M. Madić, V. Gecevska, M. Radovanović, and D. Petković, "Multi-criteria economic analysis of machining processes using the WASPAS method," Journal of Production Engineering, vol. 17, pp. 1-6, 2014.

[28]        S. Chakraborty and E. K. Zavadskas, "Applications of WASPAS method in manufacturing decision making," Informatica, vol. 25, pp. 1-20, 2014.

[29]        H. Yurdoglu and N. Kundakci, "Server selection with SWARA and WASPAS methods," Balikesir University, Journal of Social Sciences Institute, vol. 38, pp. 253-269, 2017.

[30]        E. K. Zavadskas, Z. Turskis, J. Antucheviciene, and A. Zakarevicius, "Optimization of weighted aggregated sum product assessment," Electronics and Electrical Engineering, vol. 122, pp. 3-6, 2012. Available at:

[31]        E. Ayyildiz and M. Murat, "Determination of education performance of the cities located in Turkey using multi-criteria decision making methods," Urban Academy, vol. 10, pp. 255-267, 2017.

[32]        E. K. Zavadskas, J. Antucheviciene, J. Šaparauskas, and Z. Turskis, "Multi-criteria assessment of facades’ alternatives: Peculiarities of ranking methodology," Procedia Engineering, vol. 57, pp. 107-112, 2013. Available at:

[33]        J. Saparauskas, E. K. Zavadskas, and Z. Turskis, "Evaluation of alternative building designes according to the three criteria of optimality," Proceedings of the 10th International Conference on Modern Building, Structures and Techniques, May 19-21, Vilnius, Lithuania, 2010.

[34]        G. Stojić, Z. Stević, J. Antuchevičienė, D. Pamučar, and M. Vasiljević, "A novel rough WASPAS Approach for supplier selection in a company manufacturing PVC carpentry products," Information, vol. 9, pp. 1-16, 2018. Available at:

[35]        D. W. Miller and M. K. Starr, Executive decisions and operations research. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc, 1969.

[36]        E. Triantaphyllou and S. H. Mann, "An examination of the effectiveness of multi-dimensional decision-making methods: A decision-making paradox," Decision Support Systems, vol. 5, pp. 303-312, 1989. Available at:

[37]        K. Pazek, C. Rozman, V. Pavlovic, A. Cerenak, and M. Pavlovic, "The multi-criteria decision model aid for assessment of the hop cultivars (Humulus lupulus L.), Genetics, plant breeding and seed production," presented at the 44th Croatian & 4th International Symposium on Agriculture, 2009.

[38]        N. Bilir and A. Sofu, "Estimation of productions for reproductive characters in seed orchards of Pinus sylvestris by fuzzy logic model approaches," presented at the Seed Orchard Conference. Jeju, Korea, 2009.

[39]        M. Pavlovic, A. Cerenak, V. Pavlovic, C. Rozman, K. Pazek, and M. Bohanec, "Development of DEX-HOP multi-attribute decision model for preliminary hop hybrids assessment," Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, vol. 75, pp. 181-189, 2011. Available at:

[40]        A. E. Idris, K. A. Mohamed, and H. I. Mohammed, "Using regression indices and multiple criteria analysis for study of some rice genotypes under interaction of variable environmental conditions," American Journal of Experimental Agriculture, vol. 2, pp. 407-425, 2012. Available at:

[41]        K. A. Mohamed, A. E. Idris, H. I. Mohammed, and K. A. O. Adam, "Ranking rice (Oryza sativa L.) Genotypes using multi-criteria decision making, correlation and path coefficient analysis," British Biotechnology Journal, vol. 2, pp. 211-228, 2012. Available at:

[42]        H. Küçükönder, S. Boyaci, and A. Akyüz, "A modeling study with an artificial neural network: Developing estimationmodels for the tomato plant leaf area," Turkish Journal of Agriculture and Forestry, vol. 40, pp. 203-212, 2016. Available at:

[43]        E. Gemici, C. Yücedağ, H. B. Ozel, and E. Imren, "Predicting cone production in clonal seed orchard of Anatolian black pine with artificial neural network," Applied Ecology and Environmental Research, vol. 17, pp. 2267-2273, 2019. Available at:


Google Scholor ideas Microsoft Academic Search bing Google Scholor


This study received no specific financial support.

Competing Interests:

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.


All authors contributed equally to the conception and design of the study.

Related Article

( 1 ) Breeding Objective, Breeding Practices and Selection Criteria of Indigenous Sheep in Western Amhara, Ethiopia
( 2 ) Evaluation of Leaf-Water Relation Traits, as Selection Criterion for Developing Drought Resistant Potato (Solanum Tuberosum L.) Genotypes
( 3 ) Selection of Superior Clones by the Multi-Dimensional Decision-Making Techniques in Scots Pine Seed Orchard
( 4 ) Heat Tolerance Stability of Bread Wheat Genotypes under Early and Late Planting Environments through Stress Selection Indices
( 7 ) Maximizing the Productivity of Olives by Using Some Materials and Its Impacts on the Quality Indices of Picual Olive Oil
( 8 ) Studies on Seasonal Performance of Newly Developed Bivoltine Silkworm (Bombyx Mori L) Hybrids Tolerant To Bmnpv and Effect of Temperature on Disease Induction
( 9 ) Identification of Cattle Persistently Infected With BVDV (PI) By Ear-Notch Testing In Southeast of Iran
( 10 ) Protective Effects of Sweet Orange Peel (Citrus Sinensis L.) The Induction of Micronuclei Induced by Cyclophosphamide in Human Peripheral Lymphocytes
( 11 ) “Evaluation of Phytochemical Constituents of the Fruits of Cucumis Sativus Linn. For their Hepatoprotective Activity by Molecular Docking Studies”
( 12 ) Management of Root-Knot Nematode, Meloidogyne Javanica Infecting Sunflower by Some Composted Plant or Animal Residues as Soil Amendments in Egypt
( 13 ) Effect of Contamination by Fungi and Yeast on the Physiochemical Characteristics of Gum Arabic Stored in Semi-Desert Climate of Khartoum City, Sudan
( 14 ) Evaluation of Chemical-Nutritional Characteristics of Rainbow Trout Samples Affected by the
( 15 ) Biochemical and Electron Microscopic Changes Induced by Giardia in Experimentally Infected Lambs
( 16 ) The Evaluation of Some Dietary Fiber Rich by-Products in Ice Creams Made from the Traditional Pudding - Kesme Muhallebi
( 17 ) Comparing Post-Partum Growth by Body Weight between Sex and Litter Size of Agouti (Dasyprocta Leporina) Offspring from Birth to 360 Days Old
( 18 ) The Domestic Livestock Resources of Turkey: Silkworm (Bombyx Mori, L. 1758) (Lepidoptera: Bombycidae) Lines and their Conservation
( 19 ) Improvement of Maize Productivity (Zea Mays L.) by Mycorrhizal Inoculation on Ferruginous Soil in Center of Benin
( 20 ) Sooty Mold on Lemon Trees - First Recording from El-Beida City, Libya
( 21 ) Performance of Growing Grasscutters Fed Diets with Varying Levels of Soybean Meal Replaced by Brewers Dried Grain
( 22 ) Farm and Disease Management by Commercial Poultry Farmers
( 23 ) Purple-Blue Pigmentation Production as a Sign of Immune Response by Bleached Corals to Avoid Stress Caused by Elevated Sea Surface Temperature
( 24 ) Characterization and Classification of Cropland-Soils Affected by Erosion in Igbudu Ikwo, Southeastern Nigeria
( 25 ) Estimating Reference Evapotranspiration by Hargreaves and Blaney-Criddle Methods in Humid Subtropical Conditions
( 26 ) Evaluation of Bread Making Performance of Some Wheat Flour Brands Available in Nigerian Markets as Affected by Cassava or Sweet Potato Flour Inclusion
( 27 ) Utilization of Food Processing Technologies by Women Farmers in Umuahia Agricultural Zone, Abia State, Nigeria
( 28 ) Quality Attributes of Yam (Dioscorea rotundata) Flour as Affected by Some Processing Parameters
( 29 ) Comparative Analysis of Reference Evapotranspiration by Hargreaves and Blaney-Criddle Equations in Semi-Arid Climatic Conditions
( 30 ) Reference Evapotranspiration by Hargreaves and Modified Hargreaves Equations under Semi-Arid Environment
( 31 ) Characterization of a Novel Floral Mutation Induced by Gamma Irradiation of Philippine Rice Variety NSIC Rc9 (Apo)
( 33 ) Soil Properties and Growth of Maize as Affected by Slope Position and Fertilizer Type on Coastal Plain Sands
( 36 ) An Analysis of the Pre and Post Harvest Management Techniques in Rice Production: The Case of Unvda Ndop, North West Region, Cameroon
( 37 ) Application of Agroforestry Techniques in the Management of Bamboo
( 38 ) A Pictorial Guidebook on Poultry Diseases; Diagnostic Techniques and their Effective Treatment
( 41 ) Soil Respiration, Microbial Biomass and Ratios (Metabolic Quotient and Mbc/Toc) As Quality Soil Indicators in Burnt and Unburnt Aleppo Pine Forest Soils
( 42 ) Effect of Different Concentrations of Vermicompost (Biohumus) On the Root Collar Diameter and Height Growth in the Seedlings of Anatolian Black Pine
( 43 ) The Effects of Magnetic Field on Germination of Seeds and Growth of Seedlings of Stone Pine
( 44 ) An Example of Non-Wood Forest Products in Turkey: Production of Pine Nuts
( 45 ) Patterns of Plant Community Formation and Vegetation Structure in the Afro- Alpine Vegetation of Simien Mountains National Park, Ethiopia
( 48 ) Flaxseed Nutritied Meat Balls With High Antioxidant Potential
( 49 ) Protective Bioactivity of Moringa (Moringa Oleifera Lam.) Seed Oil against Callosobrochus Maculatus (F.) Infestation in Stored Cowpea (Vigna Unguiculata L. Walp.)
( 50 ) Curative Bioactivity of Moringa (Moringa Oleifera Lam.) Seed Oil against Callosobruchus Maculatus F. Infested Cowpea (Vigna Unguiculata L. Walp.) Grain in Storage
( 52 ) Effect of Sowing Date on Maize Seed Yield and Quality: A Review
( 53 ) Germination Effects of Purposive Bruchid Screening of African Ebony (Dalbergia Melanoxylon) Seeds In the Arid and Semi-Arid Region of South Eastern Kenya
( 54 ) Hot Water Enhanced Germination of Leucaena Leucocephala Seeds in Light and Dark Conditions
( 55 ) Evaluation of In Vitro Protocols for Elimination of Banana Streak Virus from Tissue Cultured Explants in Banana Seedling Production
( 56 ) Chemical Analysis of Acacia Ehrenbergiana (Salam) Tree Fruits (Seed and Pods) As Dry Season Supplement For Livestock in Arid and Semi –Arid Lands of Sudan
( 57 ) Technical-Economic Efficiencies of Snakehead Seed Production Under Impacts of Climate Change in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam
( 58 ) Synthesis of Biodiesel from Tropical Almond (Terminalia Catappa) Seed Oil
( 60 ) Heterosis for Nitrogen Fixation and Seed Yield and Yield Components in Chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.)
( 61 ) Effect of Soaking on the Nutritional Values of Kordala (Maerua Pseudopetalosa) Seeds Grown in Kordofan Region, Sudan
( 62 ) Influence of Biochar and Poultry Manure on Weed Infestation and Growth of Arabica Coffee (Coffea Arabica) Seedlings