Contact Us

For Marketing, Sales and Subscriptions Inquiries
2637 E Atlantic Blvd #43110
Pompano Beach, FL 33062

Conference List

International Journal of Education and Practice

February 2014, Volume 2, 2, pp 21-34

Incorporating Error Analysis Approach into the Teaching of Practical Chemistry in Senior Secondary Schools in Makurdi Nigeria: Any Effect on Achievement?

Emmanuel E. Achor


Rose U. Kalu

Emmanuel E. Achor 1
Rose U. Kalu 2

  1. Department of Curriculum & Teaching, Benue State University, Makurdi, Nigeria 1

  2. Padopads Harmony Secondary School, Makurdi, Benue State Nigeria 2

Pages: 21-34

DOI: 10.18488/journal.61/2014.2.2/

Share :


This study focused on the effect of incorporating error analysis approach in teaching practical chemistry on students’ achievement in senior secondary (SS) school chemistry. The study was carried out in Makurdi Metropolis using SS2 chemistry students. Both purposive and simple random sampling techniques were employed to select the sample (N = 132) from the 28 government approved schools. Four intact classes were used and the members of these intact classes constituted the sample. Practical Chemistry Achievement Test (PCAT) was used for data collection. Using Spearman Rank Order, the reliability coefficient of PCAT was found to be 0.71.  The data collected were analyzed using mean and standard deviation to answer the research questions while Analysis of Covariance (ANCOVA) was used to test the hypotheses at 0.05 level of significance. The findings reveal that the experimental group showed significant mean gain in achievement towards chemistry learning (P = 0.0001 < 0.05). On the basis of gender there was no significant difference in the achievement of both boys and girls in the experimental group (P = 0.775 > 0.05). Some of the recommendations among others are that chemistry teachers should be trained in the use incorporating error analysis approach as a teaching strategy and that chemistry teachers should be motivated not to restrict themselves to the subject contents only but teach practical along with identified errors also.

Contribution/ Originality


Chemistry practical, Error analysis, Qualitative analysis, Quantitative analysis, Teaching practical, Chemistry achievement


  1. Achor, E.E. and M.A. Ejigbo, 2006. A guide to writing research report. Kano: Sam Artrade Limited.
  2. Akinsola, M.K. and I.O. Igwe, 2002. The relative effect of metacognitive strategy of framing on students achievement in selected difficult chemistry concepts. Journal of Science, Teachers Association of Nigeria, 23(1 & 2): 20-28.
  3. Akpoghol, T., 2001. Poor performance in science subjects amongst secondary school students in Makurdi: Causes and possible solutions. Unpublished, P. G. D. E. Project, Benue State University Makurdi.
  4. Akpoghol, T., 2006. Effect of problem solving strategy on students’ achievement and retention in secondary school chemistry. Unpublished M.Ed. Project of Benue State University.
  5. Anaekwe, M.C., 2006. Outcome of science and technology implication for national development. STAN Journal, 67(3): 60- 75.
  6. Asim, E.A., 2008. An impact evaluation of a science project on science learning outcomes. In Nsikak- Abasi Udofia (Ed) theme curriculum development in science, technology and mathematics. Science Teachers Association of Nigeria Proceedings of 49th Annual Conference. Ibadan: HEBN Publishers. pp: 57-62.
  7. Awa, R., 2003. Analysis of secondary school students’ error in practical chemistry. Unpublished M.Ed Project, University of Nigeria Nsukka.
  8. Bichi, S.S., 2002. Effect of problem solving strategy and enriched curriculum on secondary school students achievement in evolution concepts. A Ph.D Dissertation, Ahmadu Bellow University Zaria, Nigeria.
  9. Bounce, D.M., 2001. Concept learning versus problem solving. Journal of Chemical Education, 67(6): 253-254.
  10. Chukwuneke, B.U. and C.O. Nwachukwu, 2005. State and future education in Nigeria. In J. O. Afe & G. C. Edozie (Eds), Book of abstracts and lead papers. Asab West: Solomon Publishing Company. pp: 58-59.
  11. Dimitrov, D.M., 2002. Gend difference in science achievement: Differential effect of ability, response format and strands of learning outcomes. School Science and Mathematics, 99(2): 445 – 450.
  12. Duguryil, Z.P., 2004. Students’ achievement in JSSCE integrated science as a predictor to their performance in SSCE chemistry. Unpublished M.Sc. Thesis University of Jos.
  13. Federal Republic of Nigeria (FRN), 2004. National policy on education. Lagos: NERDC Press.
  14. Hebden, J., 2005. Chemistry teaching strategies. Retrieved on April, 20th 2010. Available from www /resources/.../chem.% 20 strategies pdf.
  15. Ibem, V.O., 2006. Impact of incorporating error analysis strategy in teaching selected topics in chemistry on students’ attitude towards senior secondary school chemistry. Unpublished M.Ed Thesis, Abia State University, Uturu.
  16. Ihuarulam, A.I., 2008. Chemistry teachers’ perception of availability and state of resources for curriculum development in Kano State. 49th Science Teacher Association of Nigeria Conference Proceedings. Lagos: Heinaman Book (Nig) Plc.
  17. Julie, P., 2004. STSS: A step survival annual by self guide to data analysis using SPSS for windows. Gals Glow: Bell and Baim.
  18. Lawan, K., 2006. Gender related difference in errors analysis of some Nigeria high school students in practical biology. Published Research Report 143, Eric CSMEE, ED 393698 Columbus Ohio.
  19. Okafor, P.N., 2003. Innovations in scientific and technological literacy for sustainable development in Africa. 43rd STAN/CASTIME African Conference Proceedings. Lagos: Heinemann Books (IIg.) Plc.
  20. Oloyede, O.I., 1998. The effect of pretest, feedback and overview of senior secondary school students’ achievement in chemistry. Journal of Science Teachers Association of Nigeria, 33(1 & 2): 26-30.
  21. Onwuakpa, F.I.W. and B.B. Akpan, 2001. Some psycho- social issues on women in science, technology and mathematics education. In Nsikak- Abasi Udofia (Ed) 40th Annual Conference Proceedings of the Science Teachers Association of Nigeria. Ibadan: Heinemann Educational Books PLC. pp: 41-47.
  22. Soyibo, K., 2001. 53 erroneous labels in Caribbean and Nigerian biology text books compared. Journal of Science Teachers Association of Nigeria, 34(1 & 2): 33 – 38.
  23. Udoka, G.C., 2002. Effect of incorporating error analysis approach in teaching selected topics in chemistry on students’ achievement in senior secondary school chemistry. Unpublished M.Ed Thesis, Nnamdi Azikiwe University, Awka.
  24. West African Examination Council, 2006. Chief examiners’ reports. Yaba, Lagos: Amao Press Ltd.
  25. West African Examination Council, 2009. Chief examiners’ reports. Yaba, Lagos: Amao Press Ltd.
  26. Zumdahi, S.S., 2000. Error analysis in the chemistry laboratory. Wiki. Colby. Edu/download / attachments / 105382030 / error analysis. Retrieve on April, 20th 2010.


Google Scholor ideas Microsoft Academic Search bing Google Scholor


This study received no specific financial support.

Competing Interests:

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.


All authors contributed equally to the conception and design of the study.

Related Article

( 1 ) Incorporating Error Analysis Approach into the Teaching of Practical Chemistry in Senior Secondary Schools in Makurdi Nigeria: Any Effect on Achievement?
( 3 ) Investigating Linguistic Errors in English Composition: A Case Study of Non-English Department EFL Undergraduate Students
( 4 ) An Analysis of Common Errors in ESL Descriptive Writing among Chinese Private School Students in Malaysia
( 5 ) Mathematical Analysis of the Impact of Real Exchange Rate on Output Growth and Inflation: The Case of Tanzania Zanzibar
( 6 ) Comparative Analysis of Learning Styles of Students of USA and Bangladesh
( 8 ) The Importance-Performance Matrix Analysis in Partial Least Square Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) With Smartpls 2.0 M3
( 9 ) Alternative Way of Statistical Data Analysis: L-Moments and Tl-Moments of Probability Distribution
( 10 ) Analysis of Integrated Science and Computer Science Students’ Academic Performances in Physics in Colleges of Education, Nigeria
( 11 ) A Genralist Predator Prey Mathematical Model Analysis on A Cusp Point and Bogdanov-Takens Bifurcation Point
( 12 ) On the Component Analysis and Transformation of An Explicit Fifth – Stage Fourth – Order Runge – Kutta Methods
( 13 ) Consistency of a Mixture Model of Two Different Distributions Approach to the Analysis of Buying Behaviour Data
( 14 ) Analysis of an Eco-Epidemiological Model with Disease in the Prey and Predator
( 15 ) The Analysis of Entrepreneurship Program Within Higher Education (Institution Case Study of the Management of Business in Telecommunications and Informatics, Telkom University - Indonesia)
( 16 ) Seasonal Time Series Analysis on Export Performance of Hawassa Green Wood Flower Production (SARIMA Model)
( 17 ) Teacher Perceptions of the Impact of Peer Learning in their Classrooms: Using Social Interdependence Theory as a Model for Data Analysis and Presentation
( 19 ) Multivariate Analysis of EEG Data: Some Aspects of Diagnostic of MANOVA Model
( 20 ) Lecture Method Preferences, Auditory or Visual, of Ukrainian Consumers of Educational Services : A Statistical Analysis
( 21 ) Conceptual Understanding, Procedural Knowledge and Problem-Solving Skills in Mathematics: High School Graduates Work Analysis and Standpoints
( 23 ) Episodic Memories among First and Fourth Graders Early Childhood University Student Teachers, Concerning Teachers’ Behaviors: A Mixed Method Approach
( 24 ) Disaster Management: Planning and Communication Approaches Used in Organizations in Kenya
( 25 ) Repositioning School Based Teacher Management in Kenya: Global Practices and Approaches
( 27 ) Effects of Utilizing the STAD Method (Cooperative Learning Approach) in Enhancing Students' Descriptive Writing Skills
( 28 ) Investigating Employment and Career Decision of Health Sciences Teachers in the Rural School Districts and Communities: A Social Cognitive Career Approach
( 30 ) An Investigation into the Challenges Faced by a Funding Agency in Designing and Implementing a Succession Planning Programme
( 31 ) Effectiveness of E-Learning in Teaching Chemistry With Reference To Certain Selected Variables
( 32 ) The Impact of Teacher-Pupil Ratio on Teaching-Learning Process in Primary Schools: Experiences from Tanzania
( 34 ) Learning Analytics in Practice: Development and Implementation of A Support System to the Management of the Teaching Activity
( 35 ) Using Cooperative E-Learning Teaching Strategy to Enhance Students’ Creativity in Secondary School Biology: A Study of Selected Schools in Nakuru County, Kenya
( 36 ) Application of PBL Method in Beverage Technology Teaching
( 37 ) The Importance of Computers with Matlab Software in the Teaching and Learning of Geometry in Space
( 38 ) Student- Teacher and Student- Student Interaction in Second Language Teaching- Learning Environment: A Micro-Teaching Case Study
( 39 ) Teaching of Mathematics and Physics in Secondary School through Research and Study Paths
( 40 ) Effective Use of Teaching Methodologies in Science, Technology and Mathematics (STM) Classrooms in Nigeria: A Panacea to Vision 20:2020
( 41 ) Availability and Use of Instructional Materials in the Teaching of Conflict and Conflict Resolution in Primary Schools in Nandi North District, Kenya
( 42 ) Teachers’ Maxims in English Language Teaching; a Challenge in Education for Social Transformation in Kenya
( 43 ) Mainstreaming ICT Mobile in Teaching Large Classes in Higher Learning Institutions in Tanzania: The Case of Ardhi University
( 44 ) Factors that Influence Teachers’ Perceptions of Information Communication and Technology (ICT) in Mathematics Teaching in Kenyan Secondary Schools
( 45 ) Effective Application of Local Teaching Aids for Cost Control in Learning Islamic Studies in Nasarawa State, Nigeria
( 46 ) EFL Teachers Response to the Ecological Expectations of the Teaching Context at a Saudi University
( 47 ) Anxiety in Classroom Presentation in Teaching - Learning Interaction in English for Students of Indonesian Study Program at Higher Education
( 48 ) Industry 4.0: Employers Expectations of Accounting Graduates and its Implications on Teaching and Learning Practices
( 49 ) Shifting Primary School Teachers Understanding of Songs Teaching Methods : An Action Research Study in Indonesia
( 50 ) Out-of-Field Social Studies Teaching through Sustainable Culture-Based Pedagogy: A Filipino Perspective
( 53 ) Representation of Science Process Skills in the Chemistry Curricula for Grades 10, 11 and 12 / Turkey
( 55 ) Using the Semantic Differential Method to Assess the Learning Motivation and Attitude of First-Year Students towards Chemistry in University of EMERCOM of Russia
( 58 ) Counselling Against Dropout among Secondary School Students in Edo State
( 60 ) Overcoming Domestic Labour among Secondary School Students in Kenya
( 61 ) Relationship between Selected Total Quality Management Practices Employed By Public Secondary Schools Principals and Students’ Performance in Kenya Certificate of Secondary Education in Kiambu County, Kenya
( 63 ) Drug Use and Anti-Social Behaviour as Correlates of Secondary School Students’ Achievement in Biology in Makurdi Local Government Area of Benue State
( 64 ) Marketing Strategies And Students’ Enrolment in Private Secondary Schools in Calabar Municipality, Cross River State, Nigeria
( 65 ) Self-Concept as a Correlate of Secondary School Students Academic Performance in Mathematics
( 66 ) Principals’ School Plant Management and Academic Performance of Biology Students in Public Secondary Schools in Uyo Senatorial District, Akwa Ibom State
( 67 ) Preference of Learning Styles and its Relationship with Academic Performance among Junior Secondary School Students in Dutse Local Government Area, Jigawa State, Nigeria
( 68 ) Development of a Rating Scale for Measuring Teacher Classroom Autonomy in Secondary Schools in Southwestern Nigeria
( 70 ) Effects of Two Methods of Instruction on Students’ Critical Response to Prose Literature Text in English in Some Secondary Schools in Benin City
( 71 ) Challenges to E-Learning in Public Secondary Schools in Edo State in The 21st Century
( 72 ) Appraisal of Government Feeding Programme on Increased School Enrollment, Attendance, Retention and Completion among Secondary School Students in Maiduguri, Borno State
( 73 ) The Rwandan Secondary School Competence-Based Curriculum: Knowledge, Skills and Attitudes to Incorporate in the University of Rwanda-College of Education Programs to Align them with the Current Curriculum
( 74 ) Assessing Key Performance Indicators in Government Secondary Schools of Matabeleland Region in Zimbabwe
( 75 ) Predictors of the Drop in School Marks in Secondary School: Evidence for Effects of Students’ Socio-Demographic Background
( 76 ) I am a College Graduate: Postsecondary Experiences as Described by Adults with Autism Spectrum Disorders
( 77 ) School-Community Relationship and School System Effectiveness in Secondary Schools in Cross River State
( 78 ) The Profile of Professional Standards for Secondary School Principals in Vietnam
( 79 ) Effect of the Use of Video Compact Disc Instructional Package (VCDIP) on the Academic Performance of Junior Secondary School Business Studies Students in Imo State, Nigeria
( 83 ) Students’ Perception of Girlchild Affirmative Action in High Schools in Masvingo Urban, Zimbabwe